New York Attorney General Letitia James is asking a federal court to use a recent ruling against the sports prediction platform Novig as evidence in a separate case brought by the CFTC against the state. James is seeking leave to submit U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon’s decision as supplemental authority before Judge Schofield, which could undermine the CFTC’s pending motion for a preliminary injunction regarding New York’s enforcement of gambling laws.
In the Novig case, Judge McMahon rejected the company’s bid to block state enforcement, ruling that its event contracts are sports bets rather than “swaps” under federal law. The judge also criticized the CFTC’s regulatory shifts as being “calculated” to influence litigation and suggested a separate CFTC order involving a different platform appeared to be a “collusive effort” with a regulated entity. The move is part of a broader judicial trend where states and tribes have won 43 of 49 contested prediction-market rulings on similar motions.
