The Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s recent directive for prediction markets to stop blocking specific jurisdictions is colliding with established legal precedents in several federal circuits. In previous litigation regarding event contracts, the Sixth and Ninth Circuits rejected the agency’s argument that federal law prohibits geographic restrictions on market access, ruling that the Commodity Exchange Act does not require platforms to be available nationwide to be considered impartial.
The CFTC’s new guidance requires designated contract markets to end the practice of geofencing states within 30 days to ensure a uniform national scale. The mandate puts platforms like Kalshi in a legal bind, as it clashes with existing court orders banning its sports contracts in Washington, Nevada, and Michigan. Critics note the agency’s original interpretation of the impartial access rule was designed to prevent membership standards that favored wealthy participants, rather than to eliminate geographic barriers.
