The judges on a Fourth Circuit panel reached a 2-1 decision that Kalshi’s sports prediction markets are subject to Maryland gambling laws, but they disagreed on the legal reasoning behind the result. In a splintered ruling featuring three contradictory opinions, Judge Thacker argued that the contracts are not “swaps” under the Commodity Exchange Act and are instead simple sports bets, while Judge Gregory concluded that Maryland has concurrent authority to regulate the markets regardless of their federal status.
The ruling brings the total record in federal appellate courts to 3-1 in favor of states challenging prediction markets. Kalshi said the lack of a unified legal argument against its business model highlights the need for the Supreme Court to settle the matter. Maryland had previously agreed to forgo enforcement of its gambling laws pending the outcome of this appeal.




