The NCAA sued DeWine and characterized the executive order as a "misguided attempt" to grant schools a "hall pass to break rules." NCAA President Charlie Baker argued that state governors lack the authority to legislate league rules, while Nebraska Attorney General Mike Hilgers called the move unprecedented for a Big 10 member state. DeWine's order was issued on the same day the 10th Circuit heard oral arguments in the NCAA's federal eligibility case involving Wisne.
