White House Counsel Will Scharf sent a letter Monday to incoming House Oversight Committee Chairman Robert Garcia warning that planned Democratic investigations into the Trump administration could “cross the line into blatant criminality.” Scharf wrote that congressional oversight must serve a legitimate legislative purpose rather than “harass and aggrandize,” adding that issuing unlawful subpoenas to deprive citizens of constitutional rights “may warrant further investigation” and that the administration “will not be extorted and will not be cowed.”
The letter cited Supreme Court precedent in Watkins v. United States to argue Congress cannot use investigations for personal aggrandizement, punishment, or criminal prosecution powers assigned to the executive and judiciary, though the New York Times noted the portion raising potential criminality cited no precedent. The warning follows President Donald Trump’s weekend directive ordering the Justice Department to investigate Democratic lawmakers for alleged extortion and Attorney General Todd Blanche’s refusal to rule out prosecuting members of Congress over oversight threats.
