Misha Komarov, founder of Alloc Init and co-founder of the Nil Foundation, has designed a tool called Bitcoin PIPES to shield payment details from public view. The proposal uses witness encryption to hide the identity of senders and receivers as well as transaction amounts by adopting a design similar to the encrypted-note and nullifier model used by Zcash. This framework operates on the existing Bitcoin blockchain without modifying the underlying protocol or requiring a soft fork, which Komarov says removes the need for a centralized party to manage the privacy pool.
Critics, including developer @mert, argue the design creates a synthetic ledger and is roughly 7 years behind the current state of Zcash. They claim the Bitcoin L1 cannot validate private states or prevent double-spending, leaving enforcement to an off-chain protocol that lacks an in-protocol method to move actual Bitcoin in or out of the system. Additional technical hurdles include a reliance on 330 TB of ciphertext for witness encryption and a vulnerability to quantum computing attacks.
