The audit revealed significant disparities in grader accuracy, with pass rates for some tasks rising from 18.8% to 43.8% when overly strict verifiers were corrected. Conversely, pass rates fell from 60.2% to 49.7% where verifiers were too lenient. In one case, a submission failed to use required GDPR and HIPAA templates but still received a perfect score of 1.0 until the update reduced the score to 0.09. These findings affect the credibility of frontier labs that cite AutomationBench on their model cards.
