Trumbull County court records show Cledith Arthur, the late stepfather of Ohio Democratic gubernatorial nominee Amy Acton, was indicted in 1974 for incest involving his 16 year old biological daughter from a previous marriage, one year before Acton’s estranged mother, Donna Arthur, married him in a neighboring county. The sheriff was unable to locate Cledith Arthur to serve a summons in the 1973 offense and the case did not proceed, according to the county file and a contemporaneous report in the Youngstown Vindicator. Republican gubernatorial nominee Vivek Ramaswamy defended his campaign’s $4.52 million statewide ad featuring Donna Arthur on Fox News on Monday morning, saying his opponents “attacked me, they’ve defamed my mother” and adding, “You never start a fight. But if you find yourself in one, you finish it.”
In the ad, Donna Arthur calls her daughter a “liar” and urges Ohioans not to vote for her. Acton and her brother, Philip Stearns, were removed from their mother’s custody in 1978 after a Mahoning County grand jury indicted Cledith Arthur on felony rape charges for sexually abusing Acton when she was between ages nine and 12. After pleading not guilty and posting bond, Cledith Arthur fled the state with Donna Arthur, remaining a fugitive and married to her until his death in 2004. Ramaswamy’s campaign recently switched from a 60 second spot to a 30 second edit that removed Donna Arthur’s claim that Acton lied about growing up in a tent, while several Ohio businesses canceled stops on Ramaswamy’s campaign bus tour over the commercial.
